Proof homosexual sex is a sin
I can prove homosexual sex is a sin.
1) Any extra marital sex is a sin.
56 comments
Prove sin exists, and you might be onto something.this proof counts for jack shit.
Good luck.
I'll make the case of #1 not being true.
But everything hinges upon the guilt complex you call sin. And sin is defined by the fairy tales you follow written by shepherds who probably spent a considerable amount of time violating their sheep. Now, logically, would you consult someone who’s into bestiality for moral advice?
The chain of logic works.prima facie the Biblical evidence falls on the side of 'it's a sin'. Thanks so much, Paul. Really. :(
Hang on, if marriage is only between a man and a woman, only sex between men and women can ever be "out of marriage" cause they're the only ones allowed to do so.
I assume you're using the Bible for your rationales?real Christian, you'd spend every waking hour campaigning against Red Lobster.
-pb
You've just used a chain of logic to try to prove the validity of a biblical assertion, but using another, unproven biblical assertion as the starting point, followed by another unproven assertion that even the bible doesn't agree with. You fail.
Okay, good try but you haven't actually PROVED homosexual sex is a sin, you've simply spouted your beliefs. What you need to do first is PROVE that extra marital sex is a sin, then we can tackle your other remarks.
Extra marital sex? Is that marital sex above and beyond the normal amount? If so, sign me and hubby up!
So, you're saying that if we changed the law to allow gays to marry, it would decrease homosexual sin. Then, let's do it. It's what god would want!
Using your logic, I can prove that humans are the actual definers of what "sin" is.society says it is, not God.
It looks like TheListener has no problem taking creative license with the Bible. Take a look at his signature...
So if inter-racial marriage was banned again, that'd be 'extramarital sex' and thus sinful, too? What about marriage between a rich man and a poor woman?
No, you can't. You have to prove that there's a god who cares about that stuff, first, and that sin is more than a construct to keep the flock in line. You can believe that it's a sin all you like, but that's not proof as not everyone believes the same things you do.
Alrighty then, you have proved that you consider homosexuality is a sin. Congratulations, now all you have to do is prove to all of us who are non-fundies why we should care whether you consider it a sin or not, when we don't care.
To me, a sin is when you do something to harm other people - things like murder, rape, violence, and robbery. Homosexuality is just two consenting adults loving each other.
All men with Scandinavian surnames are hansome, sexy and wealthy.
1) Any extra marital sex is a sin.
Yeah, not getting any sucks. Though you shouldn't condemn others for getting some when you're not.
2) marriage is only between a man and a woman
Well, in ancient times, it was the most logical way to ensure successful reproduction and continuation of the civilization.
3) ergo there is no such thing as a gay marriage
Actually, there is. The real issue is whether or not a state or nation acknowledges it.
The rest is just unnecessary to comment on.
Dear Non-Prophet, there is no (legal) gay marriage in Michigan, it's a DOMA state. However if you get married in Canada or another state you can change your name on your social security card, and hopefully your driver's license. There are a number of gay marriages that take place just north of Michigan in Canada. Are you thinking of Maine?
First, prove that the concept of "sin" has any validity in today's society.
Marriage over here is between two consenting adults, regardless of gender.
"5) ergo homosexual sex is a sin."
Good.
Why should anyone care whether it's a sin or not? All extramarital sex is sinful. I have never been married but I have had sex with five different partners (all female, sorry) in the past. And yes, it was a sin .
What of it?
"Proof homosexual sex is a sin
I can prove homosexual sex is a sin.
1) Any extra marital sex is a sin.
Right-wing Fundamental ist Christians have no right to even have an opinion on sex, never mind homosexual sex. I can prove they have no right to have an opinion on such:
1) Marriage is only between a man and a woman, as the likes of TheListener always claim. As do the doctrines TheListener's claims - and 'beliefs' - are based on.
image
“1) Any extra marital sex is a sin.”
“2) marriage is only between a man and a woman”
“3) ergo there is no such thing as a gay marriage”
“4) So without marriage all homosexual sex becomes extramarital.”
“5) ergo homosexual sex is a sin.”
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.
