Evolutionism does not 'obey the rules of logic'. Nor of science.
Such as? And I swear, if the answer to this is "Second Law of Thermodynamics" I will hunt you down, and bitch slap you. Personally.
Evolutionism supresses all other thoughts in favor of it's own.
First, evolution is a process, not an entity. As such it's incapable of suppressing anything. Second, ID has all the opportunities in the world to make it's case...it's not out fault that a paper the consists of "GOD DID IT!" will either get categorically thrown out or taped to the wall for the real scientists to get their daily giggles out of. PROTIP: For something to be a theory, it must have observable evidence, predictions, and...well be more than a statement. When your efforts focus on finding a crack and screaming that it must mean God did it because God can do anything, it just makes you look foolish. When you say evolution is impossible because a fish will never give birth to a cow, which gives birth to a mop, it just shows you have no idea what you're talking about.
And I believe your elitist attitude is the biggest problem this theory has to overcome.
WE'RE elitist. You guys are the ones who insist God made the world, nay, the universe, solely for our own enjoyment. You guys are the ones demanding that we pitch a couple centuries of scientific progress because your Holy Book doesn't say that's how it happened. You guys are the ones who seem to feel that you're immune to scientific process, and as such, because you say it and your pastor says it, it must be so. So please, I beg you. Get off the fucking cross. We need the firewood.
The average Joe on the street has enough horse sense to see the problems inherent in this theory.
No, either the average Joe doesn't understand it fully...which is more than plausible...what the average person is taught in school is a very stripped down version of things, or has been fed a strawman version of what evolution is (Like people pounding on the fact that scientific evolution adheres to Pokemon-esque principles, like a creature will spontaneously develop gills if it's underwater for long enough.) Not to mention...reality isn't a popularity concept. Just because the average Joe doesn't understand evolution doesn't make it any less true.