Quote# 61055

[referring to Mohammad having sex with 9 year old Aisha]

Is pedophilia a crime?
From the way I see it, its two people loving each other (Prophet Muhammad PBUH and Ayesha). I'll never agree that love is a crime.

except a few, FFI 49 Comments [3/31/2009 6:47:36 PM]
Fundie Index: 66
Submitted By: ixolite

Username  (Login)
Comment  (Text formatting help) 

1 2 | bottom

Informed consent, learn it.

3/31/2009 6:51:22 PM


Yeah, a nine year old is mentally and physically equipped for that, and able to make judgments and decisions like that. Sure.

You sick fuck.

3/31/2009 6:52:14 PM


...and to think, homosexuality is an abomination to fundies.

3/31/2009 6:52:30 PM


I'll never agree that love is a crime.

So you're saying a 9 year old girl is capable of loving in a sexual way, but two adults of the same sex aren't? You're one backward ass mother fucker.

3/31/2009 6:54:16 PM


Actually I always wanted to ask this but people think I'm trying to be an apologist. No, I'm asking historically--I know the Qu'ran says they get married, but does it say they have sex? Those did not used to be equivalent. Children used to be "married off" by their parents but they didn't consummate it until they 'came of age' (12+).

(Not that THAT is fine either, but it's not quite what people are assuming from modern meanings of marriage.)

3/31/2009 6:55:12 PM

Informed consent, learn it.

3/31/2009 6:56:36 PM


For a moment I thought it said FBI and I had a serious WTF.

3/31/2009 7:03:24 PM


Is having sex with a mute person a crime?
I mean, they didn't say no.

3/31/2009 7:10:05 PM


No matter what, my religion is 100% right, it cannot be wrong, in any way, no matter what. The end.

3/31/2009 7:11:46 PM


"Is pedophilia a crime?"

Well lets see the definition of a crime is any act that constitutes a threat to or damage of a society, it's inhabitants or it's structure.

Since pedophilia is an act that harms a child, a potentially great future contributor to society and scars them emotionally and physically for life which means they might need psychiatric help and the act itself goes against the foundation in society that children are sacred and treasured, yeah, I'd say it's a goddamn crime.


3/31/2009 7:25:03 PM


Sickening. May no one let their kids near you.

3/31/2009 7:29:11 PM


... please die.

3/31/2009 7:29:44 PM

Anathema Device

Sick bastard, touch my kids and find out if its a crime!

3/31/2009 7:38:56 PM

TB Tabby

Then you naturally approve of gay marriage.

3/31/2009 7:55:02 PM

Married at 6, sex at 9, wonder why she never had kids??? Hmmm, methinks perhaps irreparable internal damage.

Oh, peaceful loving religion FTW!!!

3/31/2009 8:00:10 PM

Married at 6, sex at 9, wonder why she never had kids??? Hmmm, methinks perhaps irreparable internal damage.

Oh, peaceful loving religion FTW!!!

3/31/2009 8:02:18 PM


Seeing as how it is not consenting adults yes it is a crime you sick fuck

3/31/2009 8:07:39 PM


So about stoning homosexuals?

3/31/2009 8:18:25 PM


I hope your neighbors know you think there is nothing wrong with an adult man fucking a 9 year old child.

3/31/2009 8:20:32 PM

Oy Vey!

3/31/2009 8:21:17 PM


Yeah, that's totally love. *eyeroll*

A grown dude porking a 9 year old is rape. Sorry.

3/31/2009 8:24:38 PM

Giveitaday (Forgot to add my the first time around)

Is pedophilia a crime?

Yes, In every single possible circumstance.

From the way I see it, its two people loving each other (Prophet Muhammad PBUH and Ayesha).

There is nothing to suggest that there was any love involved. IIRC marriage in that culture at the time, and still to some degree today, was an arrangement between the Groom and the brides father. A six year old girl does not have the maturity to consider the consequences of marriage to a much older man. I also doubt that she had sex with him because she really, really wanted to, but because he was her husband and she had been told all her life to obey her husband or risk being the victim of an honor killing.

I'll never agree that love is a crime

Lying for Allah(TM)! You would agree in a heart beat if it was love between two men or, possibly to a lesser degree, two women. They only reason you made the statement in the first place is so you can rationalize away child rape by the founder of your religion.

3/31/2009 8:33:52 PM


They were married when she was six years old and he 'de-flowered' her when she was nine.

So, Aisha was betrothed to Muhammad, and 3 years later, i.e. when Aisha was 9, the marriage was
consumed. And Muhammad was 53 then [SAHIH BUKHARI
1991:236,7:64,7:65,7:88] .

The 3 year waiting period probably had to do with the fact that at that time Aisha had contracted
some disease, whereby she, temporarily lost her hair. Aisha was then socially and psychologically
still a child as is evidenced by the fact that she was still given to her toys, she was unaware of
what was happening around her, and her playmates behave as would the children at present times
[Sahih Bukhari 8:151,5:234].

Aisha became Muhammad's favourite wife. And the sexuality in the relationship was predominant [
SAHIH BUKHARI .1.270, 3:36, 7:6, 3:148, 3:149, 3:150, 7:142, IbnSa'd 1pg165 ]. Later, Aisha was to
be called the "mother of believers".

Link to more references...

3/31/2009 8:34:52 PM


Yes, pedophilia is a crime. It is not dependent on what you see or don't see. It matters not in the least if you agree or disagree. It doesn't matter what precedents there may have been in ancient history. Here, today, it is a crime.


3/31/2009 8:38:29 PM


re: ausador

Thank you! YIKES.

I don't know Islam very well at all and had no idea where to look for that info.

3/31/2009 8:41:38 PM

1 2 | top: comments page