1
#271572
Robbie
Stay with me.
Logically impossible means that the two situations CANNOT exist simultaneously: if He can create a rock that He cannot lift, but also be able to lift it, then he did not create a rock that He cannot lift.
It's not really all that difficult.
7/29/2007 2:42:00 PM
#271577
Viva
Logic is not really your thing is it?
7/29/2007 2:53:43 PM
#271607
Lamb of the Invisble pink unicorn
Logic motherfucker, do you have it?
7/29/2007 3:50:27 PM
#271615
...
Anyone think that last part sounds like an advert for some cheap sporting clothes...
7/29/2007 4:08:50 PM
#271625
Freboy
Sounds like the philosophical classic "all we know is that we know nothing".
7/29/2007 4:21:02 PM
#271626
Sideshow Bob
Neo's changed his gender and taken up internet preaching. :D
7/29/2007 4:23:22 PM
#272198
Frank
can he drive out people with iron chariots?
7/31/2007 12:50:21 PM
#272208
skyotter
i may get flamed for this, but i can't disapprove of Theresa's logic
it's like a Schrodinger's Cat thing -- God both can and cannot lift the rock
sure, it's a "logical impossibility" (or at least counter-intuitive), but so is an infinite/omnipotent/omniscient God
at least the "yes AND no" answer is consistent (just not self-consistent, heh)
7/31/2007 2:25:19 PM
#272209
Jim
Quantum mechanics sorta doesn't have the God factor.
If God, then no QM.
Thus...
7/31/2007 2:27:11 PM
#272238
Raewyn
I... I need to lie down. My brain hurts.
7/31/2007 5:42:58 PM
#272446
Someone
Logic. Logic Logic Logic.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logic
8/1/2007 7:38:17 AM
#273252
Guy
Well... it's a fair enough response to those who say god is not omnipotent if he can't perform a paradoxical feat. The only solution is to say that God is beyond logic.
8/3/2007 12:03:21 PM
#273298
agentCDE
So gods are outside of logic. What else is new?
8/3/2007 2:30:28 PM
#930890
Tormentor of Religion
Been said before, on this very comment section, in other words, but, here goes...
LOGIC DOES NOT WORK THAT WAY!
Now please go fuck yourself with a red-hot iron, that way you will never have kids to carry on your stupidity.
3/29/2009 9:22:25 AM
#930904
WMDKitty
Um... wha...?
3/29/2009 9:34:38 AM
#930918
smartz
What's this? A rock that God can and cannot lift? This is the most insane thing I have read a fundamentalist say yet.
Key word: Yet.
3/29/2009 9:51:24 AM
#1089842
Godbuster
If god is outside logic then he should have no bearing on our day to day lives, because how can we rely on something that must be random, as it's outside of the bounds of logic.
1/6/2010 7:05:37 PM
#1089844
Nowonmai
So, for your next step in illogic, you will try to divide yourself by Zero?
1/6/2010 7:12:40 PM
#1373654
Hell orBust
morpheus was my favorite character from the matrix too, but i dont think being incredibly badass makes you god.... or maybe it does, gods actions scream of despotism.
2/10/2012 9:56:05 AM
#1373656
Justanotheratheist
Do you have any idea how fucking stupid that is?
No, clearly not.
2/10/2012 9:58:23 AM
#1393318
Hairysteed
Doublethink
You has it!
4/16/2012 1:47:57 PM
1