Home Archives Random Quotes Latest Comments Top 100 Submit Quote Search Log In

Quote# 8811

I just debated an evolutionist on EVC forum who made the false statement that apes & humans can interbreed. This is the kind of lie on which the theory of evolution is based. He admitted it, and I proved the theory of evolution is a lie so we ended the debate.

Heidi, 123 Christian Forums 15 Comments [12/30/2005 12:00:00 AM]
Fundie Index: 6
WTF?! || meh
Username:
Comment:



1
The Dapper Waffle

Here's the thread where Carico showed that \"the theory of evolution is a lie.\" http://www.evcforum.net/cgi-bin/dm.cgi?action=msg&f=8&t=140&m=1

12/31/2005 7:51:21 AM

Dragon

Wait... ONE idiot disproves the whole theory?!? This site is obviously proof creationism is false!

12/31/2005 8:53:14 AM

glyptodon

Haha, yes, if one person says something incorrect about evolution then EVOLUTION IS A LIE.

Hm, that must be why creationists make up such ridiculous strawmen!

How much do you want to bet that the \"evolutionist\" who supposedly said that apes and humans can interbreed was saying something completely sensible, that the other party simply didn't understand, a la the Carico thread?

12/31/2005 9:10:07 AM

Acetv

Indeed, Nuggin (a.k.a. the \"evolutionist\") stated:

\"Apes are not a species. \"Apes\" refers to the superfamily Hominoidea. That superfamily contains the family Hylobatidae (gibbons and \"lesser apes\") and the family Hominidae (gorillas, chimps, humans, bonobos, orangs - the \"great apes\").\"

He then went on to say that as humans are, in fact, apes, humans can therefore breed with apes.

Not the best way to state it, but it's pretty obvious what he's trying to convey.

12/31/2005 10:23:03 AM

NonHomogenized

Ah, as with the last couple of threads Carico was in over in EVCforum, she makes an idiotic assertion, gets called on it, repeats the assertion, gets told just how dumb the assertion is, repeats the same assertion, and then declares victory, as well as informing her opponent of their concession.

12/31/2005 10:28:20 AM

Darth Wang

Not again. What level of education does this woman have?

12/31/2005 3:43:29 PM

Jeremy

Next month, Heidi is getting an award for Creationist of the Year 2005. Please make it happen Yahweh.

12/31/2005 9:14:36 PM

Phil

This is how she \"proved the theory of evolution is a lie.\"

After failing spectactularly to understand that Humans ARE by definition Apes, Nuggin posted the following definition of \"ape\" from Wiki (which Carico was using for definitions elsewhere):

--------

\"Apes are the members of the Hominoidea superfamily of primates, including humans. Currently, there are two families of hominoids:

* the family Hylobatidae consists of 4 genera and 12 species of gibbons, including the Lar Gibbon and the Siamang, collectively known as the \"lesser apes\"

* the family Hominidae consisting of gorillas, chimpanzees, orangutans, and humans, collectively known as the \"great apes\".\"

-------

To which she responded:

\"The debate between you and me is over because you can't see the difference between humans and apes and cannot see that we cannot breed with apes. Therefore, I will not debate with someone who makes false statements.\"

That was the end of the thread.

So I'm not sure where she thought \"He admitted it, and I proved the theory of evolution is a lie so we ended the debate.\"

In fact, it resulted in her posting priveleges being revoked because she couldn't understand such simple principles in debate (as in, definitions).

12/31/2005 9:56:13 PM

PenetratingShaftOfTruthAndSemen

Good, i'm glad she finally suffered some consequences for her idiocy. They were giving her a free pass there for way too long. I read that entire thread and was disgusted by how stupid and juvenile one person could act. I personally think she has some sort of undiagnosed autism.

12/31/2005 10:37:30 PM

Redhunter

I too have followed some of her threads and it is absolutely maddening how stubborn she can be. She hears what she wants, lies, and repeats herself over and over and over.

On top of it she claims to have studied evolution (take that as you will) for thirty years, yet she still believes that evolution is about humans having sex with monkeys. Truly a freak of nature.

7/27/2006 7:25:46 AM

Robbie

It's official:

Carico doesn't understand words.

This is how that "debate" went:

(Note that these are all paraphrases)

OTHER GUY: I think we can both agree that we should start with the very basics. Evolution heavily implies a very old Earth, right?

CARICO: NO! The Earth isn't millions of years old! God says so!

OTHER GUY: Carico, I'm not asking you to agree that the Earth is millions of years old, just that a very old Earth is involved, however indirectly, with the theory of evolution.

CARICO: NO! The Earth isn't millions of years old! God says so!

OTHER GUY: But that ...

CARICO: MOVING ON! The theory of evolution says that zebras can suddenly turn into apples.

OTHER GUY: Not even close. A.) Those are two existing species, and evolution is the modification of a species into an entirely new species, that is, the end result couldn't breed with its ancestors.

CARICO: But wouldn't apes have to breed with humans to produce humans? [The total disregard for logic, and the implication that evolution states that a species can only be produced by members of its own (currently existing) species breeding, possibly with members of other species, hurt me to write.]

OTHER GUY: Well, humans are apes.

And the rest is history.

12/27/2007 1:21:13 PM

Sigmund Freud

You are sick, Heidi.
You need a few weeks of discipline.
Do you like red leather or black?

12/27/2007 1:49:46 PM

Philbert McAdamia

{ CARICO: MOVING ON! The theory of evolution says that zebras can suddenly turn into apples. }

I once saw a taxi cab turn into an alley . . .
*badda BOOM*

_______________________________________________

This thread reminds me of "Murder In The Rue Morgue"

12/27/2007 2:08:21 PM

cyborgtroy

I read the thread and you completely misinterpreted him.

Let's have a fun analogy:

Evolutionist: "Red is a color. Blue is a color."

Carico: "So red is blue?"

Evolutionist: "No, red and blue are different sorts of colors, but they're both colors."

Carico: "So you can't mix red and blue?"

Evolutionist: "No, you can, because they're both colors."

Carico: "So red and blue are the same?"

5/9/2008 8:22:31 AM

Ebon

You are lying. That exchange didn't happen the way you claim it did.

9/2/2012 10:30:57 AM
1