Hitler was only killing the races that plague this world.
Mass deportation and then separatism would have been a bit more humane, I agree.
Now watch as all the bleeding heart liberals jump up and shout "MUH DIVERSITY" and "MUH TOLERANCE."
I believe in nationalism. Each country for its own people, if gypsies and Jews didn't invade Germany, Hitler wouldn't have had to exterminate them.
31 comments
if gypsies and Jews didn't invade Germany, Hitler wouldn't have had to exterminate them.
Somehow I'm betting this idiot has no problem with white people "invading" North America.
"Each country for its own people, if gypsies and Jews didn't invade Germany, Hitler wouldn't have had to exterminate them."
As a German with a good knowledge of the history of his "own" country, and the countries around him, I can tell you when "Germany" was thought of as a potential nation state, the Jews and gypsies had been here for centuries. Not that German Jew is an oxymoron, neither German gypsie.
Needless to say, this is spectacularly racist. Jews and Slavs and Roma didn't "invade" anything, and if you think they did, then you are one sick puppy.
Damn those Slavs for invading Germany by throwing themselves under panzers that just happened to be crossing Poland from West to East. It wasn't an invasion, honest, the Wehrmacht were just a bit lost.
Supposing, by his language, the OP to be American, I challenge you to look up what Hitler had to say about your 'people' and see if you still think he was a good guy.
" if gypsies and Jews didn't invade Germany, Hitler wouldn't have had to exterminate them."
If Germany hadn't created itself by annexing various little states that had existed for centuries, with Jews and Gypsies as mostly welcome members of society, then there wouldn't have been a problem in the first place.
"Hitler was only killing the races that plague this world.
For the first time we now see here an anti-slavist neonazi!Lebensraum and the way of the Paners and cowardly aggressed the poor peace-loving Third Reich by their mere existence.
"I believe in nationalism. Each country for its own people, if gypsies and Jews didn't invade Germany, Hitler wouldn't have had to exterminate them."
These Jews and Gypsies were fully integrated in the life of their country since several centuries and were used as craftsmen, bankers and entertainers by the locals.Wehrmacht and which were intended to be colonised Tasmania style by the Nazis.
[edit] Are you really thinking "mass deportation and then separatism", ie driving peoples out from their homes to arbitrarily defined "homelands", humane?
Notary, you have convinced me, through this speech, that there are indeed lives not worth living. Now, get in the gas chamber.
To the Nazis, any race or culture even slightly different than theirs was a plague on the world. If the Axis hadn't lost, eventually they would have exterminated everyone, then turned on each other the same way Hitler backstabbed Stalin. That's the way these things work.
Each country with its own people?
@ScrappyB: Ehrm, no. The Nazis had plans to exterminate several "races", but wanted to keep several others around in race-slavery system of sorts - the slavs for example were thought of as future slaves to the Aryan race, while the only two races that were lower - Jews and Gypsies - were deemed "life unworthy of life" and to be exterminated.
The Nazi's were bigoted hate-filled genocidal maniacs, they weren't suicidal.
Actually, near the end of the Nazi Germany Hitler had concluded that Slavics were the superior people because Stalin had thrashed him so hard. He wanted Germany to give up for being inferior.
So continuing his Insane Troll Logic, it means that if you aren't a Slav, you should prepare to be enslaved or die.
"Gypsies" never invaded anyplace. They lacked an army.
I've been accosted by jews for my obvious "racial impurity", and told flat out that I am an "abomination" that should be killed... but I think I would rather side with jews than with wannabe neo-nazis.
None of these groups are actually races, as far as I'm aware. Slavs are Caucasians similar to Celts and Latin people. What could possibly distinguish them from the other Europeans except language? Roma and Jews are similar as well. They are identified as different purely because they maintain a distinct culture. Having said that, the Nazis defined people as Jews almost without any regard to culture or skin colour.
@whatever - Well, the Roma people are descendants of immigrants who came to Europe from what is now India/Pakistan about 1300 years ago. They're not genetically closely related to people in Europe, they're South Asiatic. But, they've been in Europe so long that a lot of them also have plenty of European ancestry flowing through their veins as well. Similar to African-Americans.
Most Ashkenazim Jews have so little Semitic ancestry by this point it's basically pointless to make them out to be nonwhite people.
@Vox: The Nazis viewed all races inferior to the Aryan race (German, Dutch, French, English, Danish, Swedish, Norwegian people). About blacks (Afro-Germans is the PC word now here), you are right, though they because there weren't many at the time, don't show up in such high numbers as Jews and Romani. Also they weren't seen as dangerous as Jews - I still think Hitler was just screwed over by Jew once...
But there is no sense in arguing about the exact positions in the hierarchy - doing a quick Google search, there seem to be at least 4-6 subcategories to the Arxan race and I'm guessing the same thing went for Jews, Romani and the different peoples of African desent. Leave it up to us pedantic Germans to make everything complicated as fuck.
@UHM - You're right. I concede my earlier hasty comment, I think I WILL leave it up to Germans in the future to make things complicated as fuck. XD
IMHO I think the reason the Nazis didn't see blacks/Africans as being as dangerous as Jews is because they believed Africans have inherently low intelligence and believed they couldn't possibly be smart enough to form a focuses nemesis to "Aryans". I think they, similar to most white racists, stereotype blacks as being violent and brutal but not too bright. I think they viewed Jews as such a threat because they viewed them as being both insidious AND highly-intelligent crafty (evil) geniuses.
What about the medieval Germans invading the Slavic lands for centuries? Or more pressingly, what about white people invading the Americas?
You lost the war, Nazi troll, and you won't ever have another shot at it as long as sane humans are alive.
I wonder how he thinks deportation of gypsies, or for that matter of Jews prior to the creation of Israel, would actually work. When someone's "humane" solution is one they obviously put no thought into, that says quite a bit.
Confused?
So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!
To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register . Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.
